Year: 2025 | Month: December | Volume 14 | Issue 4
When Documents Override Belonging: A Conceptual Qualitative Analysis of Administrative Disenfranchisement, Kinship, and Human Values under the SIR Process in India
Abhiram Dwivedi
DOI:10.46852/2249-6637.03.2025.5
Abstract:
Recent administrative initiatives aimed at revising electoral rolls in India have renewed scholarly and public debate on citizenship, documentation, and democratic inclusion. This paper presents a conceptual qualitative analysis of the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process, focusing on its implications for internal migrants who work in urban centres while maintaining enduring kinship, social, and moral ties with their native villages. Drawing on sociological theories of citizenship, bureaucracy, migration, and belonging, and supported by illustrative experiences reported in the media, the paper argues that document-centric governance may generate forms of administrative disenfranchisement that extend beyond formal legal exclusion. Voting rights are conceptualised not merely as procedural entitlements but as expressions of dignity, recognition, and social membership. When socially embedded individuals are rendered administratively invisible due to mobility and documentation gaps, the consequences include social disconnection, moral injury, and erosion of democratic belonging. By integrating sociological analysis with ancient Indian perspectives on village-centred social solidarity, the paper contributes to human values–oriented scholarship on democracy, justice, and inclusion in the Global South.
Highlights
- Examines India’s SIR electoral roll revision through a human values and sociological lens.
- Frames voting rights as markers of dignity, recognition, and social membership, not just procedure.
- Shows how document-centric verification can disenfranchise mobile, socially embedded citizens.
- Links circular migration patterns to risks of administrative exclusion from village electoral rolls.
- Integrates Weberian bureaucracy theory with ancient Indian village-centered social thought.
- Proposes kinship-based verification and ethical impact assessment as inclusive policy safeguards.
Print This Article Email This Article to Your Friend
